On a whim I tweet the options to the Property Brothers from HGTV and one of them responded back with:
@_DrewScott: I think just the sill black looks sharp
The roomie was excited that I got a tweet back since HGTV is pretty much all that is on our TV outside of a few select shows we watch.
The roomie and I have been leaning toward that one the most. Although all black in still in the running. He was going to chat with the painter next time she is there to paint and see what her thoughts are.
EDITED TO ADD
And now Michael Weatherly has weighed in:
@M_Weatherly: Current window.
Oh the dilemma!